Car service from Amagansett to Islip MacArthur Airport — Premium Black Sedan or SUV, fixed all-inclusive price, flight tracking included.
East of the hamlet, Montauk Highway runs out across the Napeague stretch, the thin strip of dunes between Amagansett and Montauk.
Expect about 70 miles to Islip, 1 hr 10 min – 1 hr 30 min on a normal day, by way of Sunrise Highway west to Ronkonkoma — no bridges and no city traffic.
The one stretch that decides the timing is Montauk Highway west of Amagansett into East Hampton and Wainscott — the slow part of any trip toward the city.
For a flight from ISP, book the Amagansett pickup about 2 hr 45 min before departure.
Holiday weekends — July 4th and Labor Day above all — need the biggest cushion of the year.
MacArthur is the closest commercial airport to the Hamptons, with one terminal and short lines.
Here's the route we normally take from Amagansett:
The same 70 miles can take very different times depending on the day. Typical times we see from Amagansett to ISP:
| Weekday, before 7 AM | 1 hr 10 min |
|---|---|
| Summer Friday, 1–8 PM (heading east) | 1 hr 30 min–2 hr |
| Summer Sunday, noon–7 PM (heading west) | 1 hr 30 min–2 hr 15 min |
| Weekday midday | about 1 hr 20 min |
| November–April | 1 hr 10 min–1 hr 20 min |
Your chauffeur collects you wherever you're staying in Amagansett. These are some of the places we pick up from most:
If you're checking out of a hotel, we time the pickup around checkout so you're not waiting in the lobby.
Staying a few days before you fly? A few things Amagansett does best:
MacArthur is the closest commercial airport to the Hamptons, with short lines and an easy curb.
An afternoon flight still leaves room for lunch in Amagansett. Two favorites:
Il Buco al Mare (Mediterranean seafood on Main Street, the first Hamptons outpost of Il Buco) and LUNCH (The Lobster Roll) (the roadside landmark on the Napeague stretch, open for the 2026 season since April).
We can start the trip from the restaurant — just put it in the notes.
How ISP compares with the other airports from Amagansett:
| Airport | Distance | Usual drive |
|---|---|---|
| ISP · Islip | ≈ 70 mi | 1 hr 10 min – 1 hr 30 min |
| LGA · LaGuardia | ≈ 100 mi | 1 hr 50 min – 2 hr 10 min |
| JFK · JFK | ≈ 105 mi | 1 hr 55 min – 2 hr 15 min |
| EWR · Newark | ≈ 110 mi | 2 hr 5 min – 2 hr 25 min |
| TEB · Teterboro | ≈ 113 mi | 2 hr 5 min – 2 hr 25 min |
| HPN · Westchester | ≈ 125 mi | 2 hr 15 min – 2 hr 35 min |
Private flyers can also use East Hampton Airport (HTO), about 15 minutes away or Montauk Airport (MTP), about 20 minutes away.
Coming the other way — Islip to Amagansett? Give us the flight number; if it's early or late, the car adjusts, with an hour of free waiting after landing.
Eastbound, the drive is quickest on weekday mornings and slowest on summer Friday afternoons, up to 2 hr.
From Amagansett, our airport car service takes the stress out of the long drive: car service to the airport at Islip MacArthur, airport transfer back, one fixed price.
Taxis charge by the meter and apps charge by demand. We charge one fixed price, set when you book — and we show up 15 minutes early, every time.
Your local car service in Amagansett: door-to-door pickups, professional chauffeurs and one fixed price.
Instant quote. Flight tracked. Driver confirmed.